15 Best Nipple Numbing Creams for Breastfeeding


Your body is still healing after a 9-month long pregnancy and the last thing you want during that special time with your child, is sore and cracked nipples. Breastfeeding can be excruciatingly painful in such cases and can take away the joy of connecting and the excitement of nursing your baby.

Nipple creams can really be your best friend if you are experiencing nipple soreness, dryness or cracking. However, the cream that you apply will inevitably be ingested by your child in some amount while nursing. Because of this, it is very important to ensure that the ingredients are completely safe.

Some of the brands have been consistently providing a quality product for years with safe and effective ingredients but they can also be very expensive. While some might be effective in healing the condition, they may contain harmful fragrants, allergic components, environmental impurities and chemicals like peg-2 stearate and triethanolamine.

Here are our top 15 picks for safe and soothing nipple creams to promote healing, soothe and prevent pain.

1. Lansinoh HPA Lanolin

If you ask your mother or a friend, the most recommended breastfeeding cream will most likely be Lansinoh, who are one of the pioneers and have been around for the longest time.

The cream contains only a single ingredient, lanolin. Lanolin is the greasy discharge from a sheep’s sebaceous glands and is highly effective in providing relief from sore nipples.

This product contains medical-grade lanolin which is chemical-free, pure and hypoallergenic. It is considered safe for babies and does not need to be removed prior to breastfeeding.

2. Motherlove Nipple Cream

This organic cream has been rated completely safe with no hazardous ingredients by the EWG’s Skin Deep Database and provides quick healing to sore nipples.

Containing organic, safe and all-natural ingredients, it does not need to be washed off before nursing. If you are looking for a lanolin-free natural product, look no further, as this product has been rated highly by reviewers.

3. Earth Mama Angel Baby Nipple Butter

Another highly preferred product for quick relief from sore nipples is Earth Angel Butter, which is non-greasy, lanolin-free and a non-GMO product.

This cream is organic, clinically-tested and non-irritating with ingredients that are completely safe for babies to ingest. Like Motherlove Nipple Cream, this too has been rated 0 on EWG’s Skin Deep Cosmetics Database. Additionally, it is priced very reasonably compared to other similar products.

4. Medela Tender Care Lanolin

Formulated with all-natural ingredients like lanolin, Medela therapy provides soothing relief and protection to new moms who experience discomfort during latching.

It’s no-mess application package makes it easy to apply. It is hypoallergenic and 100% safe for baby and mom.

Some moms have complained that this product is thick, sticky and can stain your clothes. Therefore, use a nursing pad to avoid direct contact with clothes, staining and provide better absorption.

5. Boob Ease Natural Nipple Balm

This balm has been certified organic and contains natural ingredients like extra virgin olive oil, beeswax and shea butter. It does not contain lanolin, pesticides or vitamin E and is completely safe for babies. It effectively takes the pain out of breastfeeding with sore nipples.

6. The First Years Lanolin Free Nipple Butter

Made from 100% food-based ingredients, this butter is a safe and plant-based alternative to lanolin-based products.

Backed by good reviews, it soothes, repairs and shields sore nipples. It has been enriched with milk proteins that provide advanced healing. It contains no preservatives or mineral oil and is hypoallergenic and paraben free to provide safe recovery.

7. Bella B Nipple Nurture Butter

Formulated with edible ingredients like cocoa, mango and avocado oil, it is another safe alternative to lanolin-based products. It is very helpful in healing, soothing to new mothers and eases breastfeeding.

8. The Honest Company Organic Nipple Balm

This nipple balm contains certified organic ingredients like coconut oil, olive oil and aloe vera that are edible and safe for ingestion by infants.

These food-grade ingredients are helpful in providing supple and healthy nipples with good hydration.

9. Milkies Nipple Nurture Balm

Completely organic and lanolin-free balm helps relieve and cure cracked and sore nipples.

It is safe for both mother and baby as it contains natural ingredients like marshmallow root, self heal, calendula, and shea butter without any harmful chemicals or additives.

10. Palmers Cocoa Butter Nursing Cream

This cream provides a good value for the money as it helps nursing mothers recover from dry, red and cracked nipples at a very reasonable price.

It is made using a formula with ingredients like pure cocoa butter and pro vitamin B5 that is both safe and effective for mother and child.

11. Hey Mama Nipple Cream All Natural Salve

This soothing cream protects and heals cracked and sore nipples while alleviating the pain from breastfeeding.

It has been prepared with all-natural ingredients like beeswax, coconut oil, cocoa butter, shea butter and olive oil. It is completely safe for infants as it contains no chemicals or lanolin and has a pleasant tropical scent.

12. Shea Moisture Raw Shea Cupuacu Mommy Soothing Nursing Balm

Made primarily from Cupuaçu, a plant based lanolin substitute, it helps in hydrating, healing and protecting sore nipples caused during the early months of breastfeeding.

It is certified-organic and considered safe for mother and baby.

13. UpSpring WellMom Coconut Oil Nipple Balm

This non-sticky and lightweight balm has been formulated to help nursing mothers by protecting and healing sore and chaffed nipples.

It has been made with USDA organic-certified ingredients like organic coconut oil, organic sunflower seed oil, organic cocoa and shea butters. It is free from lanolin, petroleum, paraben, gluten and GMOs and can be safely applied without having to wipe it off before nursing.

14. My Brest Friend Cream

This cream is an all-natural and organic product made from ingredients like organic shea butter, organic coconut oil, vegetable glycerin, organic mango butter and organic aloe vera.

It provides soothing relief to nursing mothers from uncomfortable breastfeeding caused by sore and dry nipples. This, too, is free from lanolin, preservatives and other chemicals that could harm the child upon ingestion.

15. Mama Mio Keep Calm Nipple Balm

This balm is an excellent blend of medical grade lanolin and organic ingredients like shea butter and coconut oil that are helpful in relieving and healing sore nipples. It is safe to apply while breastfeeding and does not need to removed beforehand.


Enjoyed 15 Best Nipple Numbing Creams for Breastfeeding? Share it with your friends so they too can follow the Superfoodsliving journey.

Share on Pinterest